Search This Blog

Thursday, January 24, 2008

What A Wonderful Day: Attended A Seminar on Birdnest Farming !!!!


This morning started my journey to Seremban, Negeri Sembilan at about 7.30 am.

I was driving at full speed and I am sure if there were any police tracking on high speed cars, I will one of them. Was running at 140 K/Hr.

The reason being, Mr Zamri, one of my birdnest friend told me that the seminar starts at 8.00 am. He was wrong and I was stupid .....

The Seminar started at about 9.00 am at Allson Klana Hotel in Seremban.

There were many prominent speakers and the best were, they represent Jabatan Haiwan, Jabatan Pertanian, Bank Pertanian, Disease Control Lab and a Birdnest Farming Developer.

The best to me is the certificate received by all attandees including a Dato. There were about 59 attendees and about 37 were Chinese and 22 were Malays.

The organiser is a Private firm called Swiftlet Impact located at Medan Mara, Jalan Raja Laut, Kuala Lumpur.

There were three exhibitors who brought with them some products that were interesting. Two showing thair range of swiftlets equipments and one was specifically on a development project in Lukut semilar to that of Eco- Birdhouse Complex in Manjung Perak.

There were so many things that I gathered and I hope will be able to write on this blog within the next few days.

Most interesting that I wanted to focus are:

1) The latest guidelines on swiftlet farming from Jabatan Perkhidmatan Haiwan.

2) Bank Pertanian Loans for Swiftlet Farming.

3) Jabatan Haiwan's specific funtions in supporting Swiftlet Industries.

Will try to crack my head during the week end. For the moment let me rest for a few hours.

Just trying to tease some of you, I bought some of those products exhibited and I am sure they will be up in my birdhouse during this Chinese New Year. Hmmm I got four full days to get more birds coming to my house .. He he he he.....

Wednesday, January 23, 2008

Breaking of Dawn: Most beutiful View To A swiftlet Farmer !!!




I am very lucky to have many friends via my blogspot.com website.

Recently I gave a friendly call to one of my blog reader who happened to be in Setiawan, Perak.

His name is Guidedstar a male and declared that he is another crazy swiftlet farming enthusiast. His wife call him by that name and he willingly accept the name.

When he received my call, he was in Setiawan. I ask him what he is up to? Yes Harry looking at swiftlet farming. Oh my god.....

Anyway I told him to capture as many pictures as possible and sent them to me.

He willingly sent a few which I would like to share will all my blog readers:



Tuesday, January 22, 2008

What Do You Think Lightning Will Do To Your Birdhouse ????



Last few days after talking to a birdhouse owner in Klang I become a bit obsessed with lightning and what it will do to your birdhouse.

In my mind I look at it as a bad thing that will totally destroyed the birds colony and all those birds will be thrown dead on the floor. I cannot imagine what will happen after that. Will my birdhouse be untenanted? Will there be a fresh flock of birds coming back? Will the smell of all those dead birds keep the new one from coming? For how long?

What happen to my sound system, those digital timers, the CCTV system, the tweeters and so forth?

Then again what do you think will happen those areas that were directly hit by the lightning? Will they be broken into pieces?

I just could not imagine the total outcome of it but what I did was to go deeper and try to understand what is lightning and how can I protect my valuable birdhouse !!!

This was what I got:

What Is Lightning???


Lightning comes from thunderclouds, known as cumulonimbus, which are created when hot moist air rises into the atmosphere and condenses. Hot air rises when heated by the sun, carrying water vapor into the sky. As it rises, the hot air mingles with colder air, and the moisture condenses into water droplets. Clouds are created when these water droplets become visible. The droplets increase in size as the cloud grows and eventually become so heavy that they fall as rain. Thunderclouds are large, anvil-shaped masses that can stretch miles across at the base, and reach 40,000 feet or more into the atmosphere.

The genesis of lightning is a subject of great theoretical debate, says Dr. Vladimir Rakov of the Lightning Research Center at the University of Florida. We know that electrical charges build up within thunderclouds, but there is no single theory that fully describes why. One commonly discussed thesis suggests that small cloud particles acquire a positive charge, while other larger particles become negatively charged. These particles eventually separate, and the upper part of the cloud becomes positively charged, while the lower part becomes negatively charged.

The attraction, or electrical potential, between the positive and negative charges eventually grows strong enough to overcome the air's resistance to electrical flow. Racing toward each other, the charges connect, completing an electrical circuit, and discharging the accumulated electricity as lightning. Cloud-to-cloud lightning is the most common form of electrical discharge. Only about one-third of all discharges are cloud-to-ground. Bolts that shoot from cloud-to-air, known as "bolts from the blue," are even less common, but can strike up to 10 miles away.

When the current is discharged, it is accompanied by a flash containing millions of volts of electricity. This is a huge amount of energy, and the surrounding air is heated up to 54,000° Fahrenheit, five times hotter than the surface temperature of the Sun. The rapidly expanding heated air also produces tremendous shock waves, which become audible as the sound of thunder.

(This world map shows the distribution of lightning around the planet. Click to enlarge and See Malaysia)

They number of strike is pretty high ....... Hmm hmm hmmmm....

Found at: http://www.thirteen.org/savageplanet/03deadlyskies/01lforms/indexmid.html

In view of it intensity and heat generated, the damage resulted are great. Let us look at a few pictures that describe its effects:


A tree is totally destroyed leaving a dead trunk with its branches thrown as far as 50 meters away.

This second picture shows a minor damage on a tall tree. Will the tree survive? Normally it will unless the roots are totally burned giving the tree no chance of functioning to absorb those essential nutrients from the ground.


Damages to life stock are unavoidable. See these dead cows found in Europe after a serious thunderstorm. All slump to the ground with very little chance to survive.



Can you imagine what it will do to your swiftlets?

Well you might say that they are protected by the enclosure but there is no proof that they are not affected?

See how a concrete slab is torn away from the wall of a building?



The good news is that there are ready made tools that you can prevent your birdhouse from becoming a torched house. I know that there are many new technologies available and it is up to you to consider to use or not to use.

I remember playing golf the other day at KLGCC (Kuala Lumpur Golf and Country Club), just one lightning strike the siren will stop our game until the lightning are at least 30 kilometers away. I ask them how do they know that? Their answer is, we have a sophisticated software system with a couple of antennas installed around the golf course to tell us where there are.

Hmm hmmm another new thing that I learned everyday ........

Treatment For Your Nesting Woods





One of the most critical item found in your birdhouse are those nesting woods.

It is known that red Meranti seem to be the preferred choice in Malaysia. Beside easily available it is also hard enought to allow multiple harvesting without damaging the wood.

Current price of red Meranti is in the region of RM 2,200 to RM 3,000 per metric ton. For a normal 20 feet by 70 feet house, you will need at least 2.5 metric tons per floor.

For two floors you need about 5 metric tons or about RM 11,000 to RM15,000. There are still the cost of labors plus those corner covers that you need to add.



What happen after a few good years these pecious woods are being attack by ants, beetles, fungus or mites?

Should they be first treated with suitable chemicals that will guarantee that they will last for at least 15 to 20 years?

If they are being treated, what kind of chemicals should be used?

What if the chemical used is so smelly that the birds refuse to stay in your house?


I am very sure that there are ways to protect your nesting woods and there are chemical that are odorless.

To me, before building up my next birdhouse, I will select the right wood, the right chemical to treat the wood and at the same time make sure my nesting woods will last for a very long time. Perhaps forever !!!!!!!

Monday, January 21, 2008

A Very Tough Question To Answer !!!

I though I have all the answers in the world to give to my blog readers.

This week received a question that I was not prepared to answer.

The question comes from a blog reader residing in Bali.

His question is very simple and it goes like this:

Dear harry,

My birdhouse have the problem where the temperature is as low as 21*Centigrade.

Can you advise what can I do?


See what I mean. This is not something that I will get from a Malaysian but an Indonesian. Maybe he was testing me on my brief knowledge on swiftlet farming.

From what I have heard and gathered, if the room temperature goes down below 24*C, there is a chance that the babybirds will freeze to death. The eggs in the nest, if they are not with their parent incubating, will also have problem in hatching. They might be frozen too.

But this is nature. Will the bird servive? Or will they migrate? I have no answers to this.

The only practical solution that I can think of is for the birdhouse owner to install humidifier that are using hot mist type.

The hot mist humidifier is similar to that of cool mist but the only different is that it has a heater to heat the water.


Just read this:

Warm-mist humidifiers

Although recommended less often than evaporative humidifiers, warm-mist humidifiers can make a room feel warmer, allowing you to bump your thermostat down a notch or two without feeling cold. Warm-mist humidifiers also offer the benefit of dispensing medications for inhalation. Since warm-mist humidifiers boil water before expelling it into the air, they kill bacteria and don't require filters so there's less maintenance expense. However, that is offset by their higher cost to run, since they use more energy than other types of humidifiers.



Found at: http://www.consumersearch.com/www/house_and_home/humidifiers/review.html

Sunday, January 20, 2008

What Shall I Do If I Found Baby Birds on My Birdhouse Floor ??



According to my records, the chances for baby birds to fall onto the floor in very slim.

If you found one on the floor then there must be some good reasons why they fall down.

The most obvious is due to hunger, says the parent have never come back home for more then two days, these bird will die so they must have committed suicide.

The next is probably due to the temperature that are just too hot to stay in the nest.

The other probability is due to a kind of attack by prediators such as snakes, rats, owl and etc. They wanted to escape and the only way out is to run out of the nest.

One of the most common is due to burgulary. These burgulars when they enter your birdhouse, they have no mercy to your baby birds. What they are there for is to harvest those white gold and they give no chance for those helpless baby birds to survive. These baby birds will be thrown on the floor and let to die. If you are lucky, you might have a chance to pick them up. Even so that is done there is no way these baby birds will survive.

Frankly if you find one on the birdhouse floor, the best advise is to quickly put them back into the nest (that also if the nest is still intact). It seem that birds have a very poor taste of smell and they will continue looking after their babies.



Should You Hand-raise a Baby Bird?

It is strongly advise you against doing this. If, however, you decide to try raising a baby bird yourself, be forewarned: rearing a young bird is an incredibly labor-intensive task.

Nestlings are ravenous eaters and must be fed every 15 to 20 minutes from sunrise to sunset. If the young bird is only a day or two old, it may be weeks before it can be released. And adults birds teach their young the skills they need for survival—where to look for food; how to avoid predators; how to communicate.

Humans simply aren't equipped to provide this essential guidance to young birds. Added to this is the problem of a very young bird imprinting on its human caretaker—becoming irreversibly socially-bonded to humans instead of to its own species. Such birds are unafraid of people, vulnerable, and often permanently dependent on humans for food—a bad situation.

All in all, despite the best efforts of human foster parents, most hand-raised birds die, often before they're even old enough to release. If at all possible, avoid rearing a bird yourself.


A Warning!


Besides being difficult, raising a wild bird in captivity is illegal unless you have the proper state and federal licenses. Call your local game warden or conservation officer for advice if you find a young bird that needs care. They should be able to put you in touch with a licensed wildlife rehabilitator who has been trained to care for sick, injured, and abandoned birds and other animals.

I hope this article give you the guide on how to handle your baby birds if they are found on the floor.....

More About Mealworms

This article about MealWorms is taken from: http://www.tc.umn.edu/~devo0028/cmeal.htm

I srongly believed that the worms can be squeezed into pulp and feed to those baby birds that are yet to open their eyes.

Since the technology in breeding swiftlet are top secrets and never before being let out of Indonesia, we can only guess !!!

Mealworms: Life Cycle

Mealworms are the larvae of the beetle Tenebrio molitor. During their life cycle these beetles undergo complete metamorphosis: egg, pupa, and adult. Times required for each stage under average conditions are listed below.



How To Culture Mealworms

Egg.......4 weeks
Larva....10 weeks
Pupa......3 weeks
Adult.....4 weeks

Culturing Mealworms

Mealworms are handy for feeding to a variety of animals, such as birds, bats, amphibians, and reptiles. To culture mealworms, use a plastic, metal, or glass container with smooth sides to prevent escape. Cover the colony with a screen; secure the screen with an elastic band. The size of the container will be determined by the number of larvae to be cultured:

wide-mouth gallon jar....1,000 mealworms
15 x 12 x 6 inches........5,000 mealworms
36 x 24 x 12 inches.....50,000 mealworms

NOTE: To discourage mites from invading the mealworm colony, place the container in a bowl of water.

Feeding Mealworm Colonies

Use any of the following mixtures:


Wheat bran

One part pulverized dry cat or dog chow + 3 parts wheat bran
Quaker oats + 1/2 cup bone meal powder + 1/4 cup multivitamin powder
Cover food and mealworms with 2-3 layers of moistened burlap. Sprinkle with water once weekly to maintain moisture level in colony. Burlap also simplifies collecting mealworms. The larvae gather between the burlap layers and can easily be scooped by hand or picked out with forceps.

NOTE: Mixtures of foods, such as oats, intended for human consumption are less likely to contain contaminates, such as mites, that can destroy a mealworm colony.

Moisture

Lay slices of apple, potato, carrot, or over-ripe banana over the surface of the colony to provide fluids for the mealworms. In addition to obtaining moisture from these vegetables and fruits, mealworms lay their eggs on them. Collect these and save them when starting a new colony.

Temperature

Mealworms thrive in a warm (80-90 degrees F) environment. To maintain the larvae in a state of dormancy, cover the container with cloth to prevent condensation, and set in the refrigerator (40-50 degrees F). Mealworms will die at lower temperatures.

Cleaning the Colony and Starting New Colonies


Over time, a build-up of powdery residue will appear in the container. This residue, called frass, consists of mealworm wastes and eggs. Sift this out once a month using a colander, window screen, or tea strainer. Keep frass in a separate container and add bran and potato slices. The eggs will hatch in about one month. Two weeks after hatching, sift out the tiny larvae and put them in a container with fresh food, burlap, and vegatable slices as described above.

PS: The breeding of mealworm is a multimillion ringgit business. They are readily exported from countries in China and USA. The worms are purchased by pet shops to be sold to people to rear birds as pets and those who love to feed their garden birds (wild).

Maybe U can start one for export.

Saturday, January 19, 2008

A Matter Of Curiosity: Are Swiftlets Color Blind ???

I was on the opinion that during my last life, I was a Swiftlet. My wife says so and I think so?

But if it was true how come I cannot remember whether I was color blind or not?

I mean how do I know which cave or which house, which area and which entrance hole that I should enter?

No one knows whether this wild swiftlet are color blind or not unless there are some scientist who are willing to conduct a test.

If they are color blind then how come I saw birdnest owners color their rooftops where the bird enters are in colors?

Hmm Hmm Hmm Hmmm ....................

I was watching this video clips on you tube and before I make any conclusion please view all of them:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3PkP1Dg1LKs

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gqsMTZQ-pmE&NR=1

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qDvHI5ztj6M&NR=1

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=22EZcnYnaIE&NR=1

After watching again and again of all these video clips, I can conclude that these birds are not at all color blind. Most of the males are very colorful to attract the females.

If they are color blind then why do not need to be so colorful?

This is why I believed that it is important for you to paint some kind of color on your rooftop or the entrance hole areas.

Just imagine if there are ten birdhouses in the same area, at least you are assured that your swiftlets will come back to the right house. (It make sense?)

Brother M specifically believed that it is good to put colors on the roof.

I believe too ......

What about U?.....................




Just look at this row of shop, do U see what I saw? Yes one of the house is colored light blue. Why ????

In Vancouver, Canada: They Rob Birdnest Shops !!!


Arrests made in bird's nest robbery

Randy Shore, Vancouver Sun

Published: Saturday, January 19, 2008

Found at: http://www.canada.com/vancouversun/news/story.html?id=7ebbd2b1-6504-419a-8274-b894385a0660&k=64397

METRO VANCOUVER /

Bird's nest is supposed to be good for your skin, your tongue and even your sex life. It is also the fuel for a string of daring robberies in Metro Vancouver.

Three armed bandits wearing masks and ball caps confronted staff at a Chinese herbal medicine store in Richmond at 1:40 p.m. Wednesday afternoon and made off with a quantity of dried bird's nest, which can sell for as much as $2,000 an ounce.

It was the third robbery targeting bird's nest in the past 12 months, according to Richmond RCMP.

The Mounties have recommended charges of robbery against all three and one will face a charge of robbery with violence. No one was injured in the robbery.


RCMP are seeking more suspects related to the crimes and are investigating whether a criminal organization is behind the robbery, or robberies, and sale of stolen nests. RCMP do not know whether all three robberies were committed by the same group.

Witnesses said that the group brandished weapons, but it is not yet clear what kind. No gun-related charges have been recommended.

Basra said language barriers have slowed the investigation.

Considered a gourmet delicacy with medicinal properties, the nests sell on local store shelves for $4,000 to $5,000 a kilo. The most expensive varieties go for as much as $1,500 to $2,000 an ounce, Basra said.

Violent armed robberies of bird's nest brokers and retailers are not uncommon in Hong Kong and Malaysia.

Two people were shot dead in Kuala Lumpur in a heist in 2002. In 2003, Hong Kong robbers tied up store staff and stole nests worth $75,000 Cdn.
Hong Kong customs officials have also made several seizures of counterfeit bird's nest products in recent years, valued at several million dollars. Large quantities of bird's nest are routinely intercepted by customs agents as part of their fight against an international black market in the rare medicinal food.

Most Chinese herbalists in Metro Vancouver stock six to 12 different varieties of bird's nest. The nests are made from dried layers of saliva produced by swiftlets, a small bird that lives in caves of Thailand and Malaysia. At the high end of the market, cave-harvested red-coloured nests (called "red blood") cost up to $400 per tael (a Chinese ounce, about 38 grams). More common white nests harvested from commercial swiftlet barns can cost as little as $50 per tael.

The health benefits claimed for bird's nest vary with the herbalist consulted. Staff at one store on Vancouver's Main Street claimed regular consumption of bird's nest, which may be served as a silky soup or a sweetened dessert, makes you look younger. Staff at the next store said it would be good for the tongue.

Most people use bird's nest for a clear complexion and "to sharpen the appetite of the old or the sick," according to Raymond Pang of Hang Loon Herbal Products in Vancouver. But the high price means he only sees one or two customers a day for bird's nest.


Pharmacist Darwin Law said the nests do contain unusual proteins and enzymes that may improve health, but the benefits are mostly "mental."

"People believe it will help them," said Law, a western pharmacist who has practised in Chinatown for 39 years. "Most people eat bird's nest to be big shots."

Friday, January 18, 2008

Pak Hen Was In Town !!!


I was so excited knowing that Pak Hen was in town.

He SMSed me a message saying that he is in Segamat, Johore meeting with one Swiftlet farmer.

I was very sure that he will be dropping by in KL. However my hope to see him did not materialised. He have finished his visit and now on the way back to Indonesia via Singapore.

Missed a very good opportunity to me some one who is very knowledgable and very easy to get along with.

Told him that I will want to see in in Kuala Trengganu during a schedule training supposed to be conducted by him in March 2008.

Well I feel great to received his SMS. I might not be buddy but to know that he remembers me in Kuala Lumpur, I am honoured.

See U pak Hen.

Let Us Know More About Termite !!!


Ever since I visited Mr. Y birdhouse at Port Klang, that was last week, my mind is so disturbed over those white creatures, the TERMITES. The damaged done to those nesting planks are costly.

I keep thinking how unfortunate it will be if it happened to me. What about if it happened to my blog readers?

If their houses are infested with these creatures it will be doom. Not exactly that, but at least they will know what to do. My advice is “Don’t panic but don't wait for it to go away. You need to take immediate action."



If they can effort, the best is to get professional exterminator. Before that they must quickly get to know more about termites, their habits and how to prevent them from entering your birdhouse and so on.

Remember they are very fond of chewing away wood. Your birdhouse has lots of wood on the ceiling of course.

Due to this reason I have decided to put some time to collect as many information as possible about termites and perhaps looks at various methods on how to keep them away.



So readers please enjoy this article (coming more) on what are termites? How it destroys your birdhouse or your home plus how can we prevent them from coming.

This "you-tube video", I think, is one of the best video clip that will tell you how smart are these white creatures. They were taken in Africa and shown on National Geographic.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0m7odGafpQU&feature=related


To make you glued to your computer chair, how about this next video? This clip shows the exact sequence of events on how termites chips away your nesting panel. See how disciplined they are in carrying out their job. They nibble one tiny piece of wood,immediately reverse backward and immediately the next in line will come in to do exactly the same. Wonderful Clip......

See this: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_navaNmibbg&feature=related

During rainy season I remembered watching flying termites coming out of their nests and perform their duties to multiply. They will fly away from their home, shed their wings, mate and start a new colony. Just imagine millions per year??

See this: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Bo0szsjCU-g&feature=related


It was mentioned somewhere that in America, termites destroys more buildings as compared to those destroyed by cyclones, floods and hurricane (in total). So you can imagine how bad they are for your precious nesting panel?

Economically Speaking !!!



Have you ever thought of how to apply your economic skill in your birdhouse ranching?

You might think that building the cheapest birdhouse and reap the maximum returns is "economically speaking".

That is not what I have in mind.

The term "economically speaking" is actually how to maximize the installation of nesting planks per floor of your birdhouse.

Different people have different ways of installing these planks. Some just leave it to the contractor to do whatever they like to do. But there are others who a immaculate in every plank that was installed.

I met one guy who told me that he is very particular about buying every single wooden plank for his birdhouses. His attitude is something that I would like my blog reader to follow or learn. He always pay slightly more the what the seller sells to him but with the condition that he has the right to inspect every single piece of the wood himself.

It seem that nearly 20% of those so called Red Meranti are actually not 100% perfect. Some sellers are unscrupulous and they mixed them with other type of low quality woods. Given the conditions he will check every single panel and reject them on the spot, those that are poorly cut (especially without proper grooves), those will grains showing irregular shapes, those that are shorter then specified, those that shows that they have soft/hard spots and etc.

From early design stage, it is possible to calculate the actual nesting space per square inch of those nesting panels that you will be installing.

You should also investigate the options to place thicker nesting planks at the site where your panel is leaning onto a solid wall or the beam structures. Main reason being when the time comes you can easily install another layer of panel, thinner, just below it.

Thicker planks helps to prevent birdshit from direct falling into those nest below it.



What about those areas below the beam? I have seen pictures indicating a three tier wooden panel that allow you to increase the nesting areas by hundred of inches per beam times two (front and back).



What about those condo wooden panel configurations? I am sure it will contribute more nesting areas in your birdhouse. If you choose the five tiers U will get 5 times the nesting areas (in principal) and if you choose 7 tiers you will get seven. What ever you select it must be proper and make sure the weight can be supported by those nails or screws that you use to hang them onto the walls or ceilings.



A nesting plank that measures let say 10 feet length with two sides of nesting areas will give you a total of 10'X 12"x 2 sides = 240 inches. If one nest takes about 5 inches, you have about 240 / 5 = 48 pieces of nests.

This is closed to 48/120 = 0.4 kilo or in RM is 0.4 X 4,500/kilo = RM1,800.

This so call small calculation gives you some ideas of the economic issue in ensuring that your house designed are well prepared to make more rooms for bird nesting areas as the house gets more populated.

Thursday, January 17, 2008

Klang BirdHouse: Visit Report Completed


Finally got the visit report completed less those pictures.

Tonight I am going thru again for the 5th time and see what else to be added or to deleted.

Once ready, I am thinking of meeting Mr Y this Sunday to perhaps give him the draft copy.

I will also will ask his permission to allow me to distribute the report to those who would like to learn from his misadvanture. If he give the green light I will do so however if he says no, I have to apologies to all those who have send in their request email.

We have to be fair to him and let him decide.

The report consist of about 16 pages of A4 document. I have laid about 24 recomendations/points which I hope he will be able digest.

These points are something that I feel very neccessary for any person in his position should try to be prepared.

I also stressed the important of learning the basics and from time to time he need to go into the micro of birdnest farming.

I am very sure that he will appreciate my findings but I want to stress that these finding are my opinion. They are not a rule or a cure to all the problems that he is facing. They might work but they might not be the only things to do ...

If I were him I will get one or two more people who are willing to help to diagnose the same problem and get their points. He can then combined all the points and select which one can be the best solutions. Perhaps he can choose some and reject the rest and set an implementation schedule to quickly get his house populated.

PS: He just informed me that he got one more person to view today. Unfortunately this person told him he know how and what to do but he will only tell him once he is given the consultancy works to renovate the bouse. I keep assuring him that most of these people are just looking at his weaknesses and going for a kill. All in all his knowledge about siwftlets is very little in deed. I asked him just be carefull and let me get the visit report by this Sunday....

Latest: Email to Mr Y a copy and asked him to review and make some comments.